Personal care product swaps for the immune side of your Hashimoto’s ⎸ Ep. 223 with Amy Enos

7–11 minutes
Amy Enos, the low tox pharmacist, and Esther Yunkin, host of Health with Hashimoto's, side by side. Text reads: personal care product swaps for the immune side of your Hashimoto's.

Personal care product swaps are one way to reduce your everyday exposure to environmental chemicals. Environmental toxins are one of the eight common Hashimoto's triggers I teach about, so this is one area to consider when working on the immune side of your Hashimoto's. Start with products you use daily and replace them one at a time.


You pick up a bottle of shampoo or deodorant that says “natural” on the front. Sounds good, right?

But turn it around and read the ingredient list. What does “fragrance” actually mean? There are so many personal care product swaps you could make; which ones should you prioritize if you’re concerned about environmental toxins being a trigger for Hashimoto’s?

That’s why I invited pharmacist Amy Enos, the Low Tox Pharmacist, to help us sort through it.

Amy teaches people how to recognize ingredients in personal care, beauty, and cleaning products. Her interest in this work began after her mother was diagnosed with kidney cancer. Her mother’s experience led Amy to start asking questions about everyday chemical exposures.

Listen on Apple Podcasts
Listen on Spotify
Listen on Audible
Listen on Podbean

Health with Hashimoto’s is your free weekly podcast that sorts this autoimmune condition into thyroid or immune. Each episode is for informational and educational purposes. Please discuss any questions or concerns with your trusted healthcare professional. Some links may be affiliate links, marked as such, at no extra cost to you.

Why personal care products matter for Hashimoto’s

Hashimoto’s is two things, not one.

Your thyroid may not be keeping up with your body’s need for thyroid hormone. But Hashimoto’s is also an autoimmune condition. Your immune system is attacking your thyroid.

Thyroid medication can help with the thyroid hormone side. But there’s also the immune side to consider.

One of the eight common triggers I teach about in Hashimoto’s Decoded is environmental toxins.

And think about how many products you use before you even leave the house.

Shampoo. Conditioner. Soap. Lotion. Deodorant. Makeup. Hair products.

Amy shared an estimate that women can be exposed to upwards of 168 chemicals through their personal care routines.

That does NOT mean 168 harmful chemicals; not every ingredient is a problem.

But when you consider how many ingredients can be in each product, you can see how those exposures add up.

Amy described it as drops filling a bucket.

Drip. Drip. Drip.

It’s a way to picture the many exposures we encounter over time. And it helps explain why she focuses on reducing what we can, rather than trying to avoid everything.

What the HERMOSA study found about reducing chemical exposure

One of the studies Amy shared was the HERMOSA study from UC Berkeley.

Researchers worked with teenage girls who were using conventional personal care products. They replaced some of those products with versions that did not contain certain ingredients, including parabens and phthalates.

Then they measured changes in the girls’ urine.

Within just three days, the researchers found measurable changes.

One of the largest was a reduction of more than 45% in propylparaben.

They also measured changes related to other ingredients, including some phthalates and chemical sunscreen filters.

Three days!

Amy pointed out that this was a relatively small study. It wasn’t the kind of large, randomized trial that can answer every question about long-term health.

And the study did not show that changing personal care products improves Hashimoto’s symptoms.

What it did show was that changing the products the girls used changed the levels of certain chemicals measured in their urine.

That’s useful information when you’re wondering whether replacing a product can actually change your exposure.

Which personal care product swaps should you make first?

Start with the products you use every single day.

Amy gave a great example. If you wear mascara four times a year, that’s probably not where you need to start.

Instead, look at things like:

  • Soap and body wash
  • Deodorant
  • Shampoo and other hair products
  • Lotion and face moisturizer
  • Laundry detergent

These are the products you’re using over and over.

You don’t have to throw everything away and buy a whole new bathroom cabinet.

Amy recommends using up what you already have, then choosing a different product when it’s time to replace it.

If you’re almost out of deodorant, start there. If you’re getting ready to buy shampoo, look at that ingredient list before you buy another bottle.

Why I started with laundry detergent

When my youngest son was a baby, he had eczema from head to toe. He was scratching himself bloody.

I was trying to figure out what was going on and what I could change in our home.

One of the first pieces of advice I got was to start with the laundry.

Think about it. You’re wearing clothes all day. You’re sleeping on sheets all night.

Whatever you’re using to wash those things is part of your everyday environment.

So I started with laundry detergent.

I couldn’t figure out every possible exposure in our house that day. But I could do the laundry.

Amy agreed that laundry products are a high-priority place to look, especially when someone is dealing with skin problems.

Personal care product swaps organized by frequency of use, prioritizing everyday products like shampoo, deodorant, makeup, perfume, and laundry detergent over occasional-use products.

Why you should look beyond the front of the label

You see a bottle with leaves on it. It says “natural” or “non-toxic.”

That doesn’t tell you what’s actually in it.

This is called greenwashing. Companies use words and images that make a product look like a healthier choice, but the marketing on the front doesn’t necessarily match the ingredients on the back.

Amy recommends learning to read ingredient lists rather than relying only on product-rating apps.

She said she has found some of those apps to be biased, and that some product verification systems involve payments.

Her preference is to learn a manageable number of ingredients you want to avoid.

You don’t need to memorize every chemical used in personal care products. Amy doesn’t know every ingredient either.

But when you start recognizing some of the ingredients that concern you, you can make decisions without depending on a rating or the claims on the front of the bottle.

Amy has a free 30 Toxins to Avoid guide to help you get started.

Comparison of a personal care product's front label with claims like natural and non-toxic and its back label showing an ingredient list with fragrance highlighted as a potentially undisclosed mixture.

Why Amy recommends avoiding fragrance

Amy said one of the easiest ingredients to start looking for is fragrance.

That one word can represent a mixture of ingredients that aren’t individually listed on the label.

Amy is particularly concerned about the possibility of undisclosed ingredients, including phthalates.

She explained that phthalates can help fragrance last longer. Think of them as little pieces of flexible plastic that grab onto the scent and hold it there.

You know how you can use shampoo at a salon and your hair still smells like that shampoo three days later? Or how some people’s laundry smells so strongly of detergent or dryer sheets that you can smell it just standing next to them?

Amy explained that phthalates can be used to make those scents stick around.

That doesn’t mean every product with a long-lasting fragrance contains phthalates, or that every product labeled “fragrance” contains them. But because fragrance ingredients aren’t always individually disclosed, you may not know what’s creating or holding that scent.

Amy would rather see the individual scent ingredients listed.

And what about natural fragrance?

I asked Amy that, too.

She has the same concern. The word “natural” doesn’t necessarily tell you which ingredients are in the fragrance mixture.

Amy’s personal rule is to avoid products listing either “fragrance” or “natural fragrance” unless she can get the ingredient information she wants.

That’s her standard. You can use that information to decide what matters when you’re choosing your own products.

Where to find lower-tox personal care products

Amy buys most of her personal care products online.

She prefers companies that make products in smaller batches and sell directly to customers. She also pays attention to changes in product formulas and company ownership.

That doesn’t mean every small-batch product is automatically safer. The ingredient list still matters.

One company Amy recommends is Pure Haven, which she uses herself. You can shop Pure Haven through Amy’s link and use code LOWTOX15 for 15% off.

Disclosure: Amy Enos is a Pure Haven affiliate and may earn a commission from purchases made through her link.

For something more readily available in stores, Amy also mentioned certain products from Dr. Bronner’s, particularly its bar soaps and body washes.

She doesn’t recommend every product from the brand. Again, look at the specific ingredient list.

Amy also has product recommendations and educational resources through her other channels:

What if the replacement products cost more?

Amy acknowledged that cost is a real issue.

A deodorant that costs $17 instead of $8 makes a difference. So does replacing a $5 cleaner with something that costs much more.

One thing Amy has noticed is that as she became more selective about ingredients, she started using fewer products overall.

That doesn’t mean the cost difference disappears for everyone.

But you can be intentional about what you buy, what you actually need, and which products you want to replace first.

You also don’t have to get everything perfect. Amy said that if she’s traveling and needs to use a product she wouldn’t normally choose, she doesn’t beat herself up over it.

Start by taking inventory of what you already use

Amy’s first recommendation was to audit what you have.

Go into your bathroom and look at the products you’re using.

Read the ingredient lists.

You might discover that nearly every product contains fragrance. Or you might find that some of your products already meet the standards you’re looking for.

Then make a list of what you want to replace.

You don’t have to buy anything today.

Start with the things you use most often, and make your next purchase an intentional one.

Frequently asked questions about personal care product swaps

One place to start

Go look at the products in your bathroom. Pick up the one you use most often and read the ingredient list. Or head to your laundry area and look at those products.

Then decide whether it’s something you want to replace when it runs out.

And if you’re still trying to figure out what belongs on the thyroid side of your Hashimoto’s and what belongs on the immune side, start with Hashimoto’s Decoded: Thyroid or Immune. It’s my short, $27 mini-course that helps you sort through those two sides and choose a starting point.

Categories:

,